5 Main Types of Rainwater Collection Systems and Their Efficiency

With different rainwater harvesting systems available, homeowners, farmers, and municipalities can significantly reduce their reliance on municipal water supplies and save money while promoting sustainable water management practices.

By Alex
7 minutes read
5 Main Types of Rainwater Collection Systems and Their Efficiency

Did you know that rainwater collection systems can be up to 90% efficient in conserving water, making them a vital tool in the fight against water scarcity (Oosterom et al. 2000; Ward et al. 2012; Fewkes. 2012; Vieira et al. 2014; Molaei et al. 2019; Raimondi et al. 2023)? Please note that the efficiency of a rainwater collection system can vary greatly based on factors such as the local climate, the size and material of the collection surface, the efficiency of the filtration system, and the maintenance of the system. With various types of rainwater collection systems available, homeowners, farmers, and municipalities can significantly reduce their reliance on municipal water supplies and save money while promoting sustainable water management practices (Yannopoulos et al. 2017).

Table 1. Different Types of Rainwater Collection System (Zhi-yun et al., 2013; Connor and Koncagül, 2014; Rahman et al., 2014; Ghimire and Johnston, 2017;  Słyś and Stec, 2020)

Type of Rainwater Collection System

Advantages

Limitations

Rain Barrels

Easy to install and maintain; inexpensive; reduces demand on municipal water supplies

Limited storage capacity; water can become contaminated if not used quickly; relatively low pressure

Direct-Pumped (Submersible)

Provides high pressure; can be used for all domestic applications including drinking (with proper treatment)

High initial cost; requires regular maintenance; electricity dependent

Indirect Pumped

Can supply water to multiple locations; water can be used for non-potable uses without treatment

Requires a pump and electricity; more complex installation; regular maintenance required

Indirect Gravity

No electricity required; low maintenance; can be used for non-potable uses without treatment

Requires elevation difference between storage and use site; gravity may not provide sufficient pressure for all uses

Cisterns

Large storage capacity; can be used for all domestic applications including drinking (with proper treatment)

High initial cost; requires regular maintenance; space requirement

Illustration of a complete rainwater harvesting system with collection from roof, underground storage, pump, and various home applications.
Fig. 1. Scheme of a residential rainwater harvesting system showing collection, storage, and multiple home uses.

In fact, the concept of rainwater harvesting can be traced back to ancient China, dating as far back as 6,000 years. Evidence suggests that rainwater capture was also employed 4,000 years ago, and archaeological findings in Israel confirm its use as early as 2,000 B.C. To this day, the ruins of cisterns constructed to collect runoff from hillsides for agricultural and domestic purposes persist in the region (Baba et al., 2018; Gould and Nissen-Petersen, 1999). Around 300 BCE, agriculture communities in present-day Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, and India began harvesting rainwater for various purposes (Lo and Gould, 2015). Different types of rainwater collection systems were used in 2000 BC in India, Mesopotamia, China, and modern-day Israel (Yannopoulos et al. 2017). The Roman Empire notably embraced rainwater harvesting on a grand scale, constructing aqueducts and cisterns to capture and store rainwater (Baba et al. 2018). In the 16th-17th century, early settlers began to use rainwater for laundry because it's naturally soft (Struk-Sokołowska et al. 2020). Today, rainwater harvesting is gaining traction as a new trend for domestic use. It is useful in irrigation, household cleaning, bathing, drinking, and livestock water, among other purposes (Lancaster 2019; Nandi and Gonela,  2022). Rainwater harvesting is still used. This is especially true in areas where water is scarce or of poor quality (Al-Batsh et al., 2019). Rainwater harvesting is not as common in urban areas due to the prevalence of non-porous materials such as concrete or tarmac, making it a major challenge for urban authorities (Coutts et al., 2013). In this article, we will discuss the efficiency and environmental impact of rainwater collection systems, as well as their role in water conservation.

An ancient, ornate stepwell in India, designed to collect and store water from rain and groundwater runoff.
Fig. 2. A view inside a historic stepwell, an ancient form of rainwater harvesting and water storage in India.

1. Types of Rainwater Collection Systems and their Efficiency

Rainwater collection systems come in various types, and their efficiency depends on the scale, technology, and complexity of the installation. Here are some of the types of rainwater collection systems and their efficiency:

1.1. Rain Barrels

This is the most common and simplest method of rainwater collection. It involves installing a barrel at a gutter downspout to collect rainwater. The actual barrel may be a recycled barrel or a new commercially available rain barrel. Rain barrels are efficient for small-scale water conservation, such as watering plants and gardens (Putri et al., 2023).

Rain barrel catchment system demonstration, showing multiple barrels used for collecting rainwater from a house gutter
Fig. 3. Example of rain barrel installation for efficient rainwater harvesting at home.

1.2. Direct-Pumped (Submersible)

This type of rainwater harvesting system filters water before it enters the storage tank. Debris such as moss, twigs, and leaves are separated from the water before it enters the tank through a calmed inlet. Another essential component of the pump assembly is an additional filter that effectively removes small particles from the water before it is pumped to the designated appliances. Once the filtration process is complete, the water is promptly delivered to the intended point of use (Retamal et al., 2009; Vieira et al., 2014; Loh, 2022).

Visual explanation of a rainwater system: rooftop collection, underground storage, and various applications including indoor and outdoor tasks.
Fig. 4. Visual guide to rainwater capture, purification, and distribution for domestic purposes like washing and irrigation.

1.3. Indirect Pumped

This system is similar to the direct-pumped system, but it uses a header tank to supply water to the pump. The header tank is filled with water from the storage tank, and the pump draws water from the header tank to supply the point of use. This system is more efficient than the direct-pumped system because it reduces the workload on the pump (Tan, 2022; Istchuk and Ghisi, 2023).

Diagram of a direct-pumped rainwater system supplying water from an underground tank to a house for daily use.
Fig. 5. A direct-pumped rainwater collection system, showing rainfall directed from a catchment area to a lower tank and pressurized for indoor use.

1.4. Indirect Gravity 

The indirect gravity rainwater collection system is similar to the indirect pumped system, but it uses gravity alone to supply water to the point of use instead of a pump. Collected rainwater from the header tank flows by gravity to a lower tank, where, by gravity again, the harvested water is distributed to the water appliances to supply the point of use. This system is the most efficient because it does not require electricity to be operated (Belhassan, 2021, Istchuk and Ghisi. 2023).

Schematic diagram of an indirect gravity rainwater harvesting setup providing water to a house bathroom.
Fig. 6. Detailed diagram of an indirect gravity rainwater harvesting setup.

1.5. Cisterns

Local people usually prefer to use a ready-made method to collect rainwater and construct permanent cisterns underground to store harvested rainwater. The collected water can then be used throughout the whole year for domestic use, such as drinking, laundry, and other uses (Wu et al., 2017). Cisterns are large storage tanks that can hold a significant amount of rainwater. They are efficient for large-scale water usage, such as supplying water to an entire household. Cisterns can be installed above or below ground and can be made of various materials, such as concrete, plastic, or metal.

Cistern system for rainwater collection: details of inlet, diverter, tank, spigot, and overflow, demonstrating garden use.
Fig. 7. Detailed setup of a cistern for rainwater harvesting, including quality protection and distribution elements


2. Conclusion

There are many ways to save water and prevent water scarcity. It is important to choose the right type of rainwater collection system based on the specific needs and goals of the user. Rainwater harvesting in urban areas is an environmentally friendly way to collect water. They can reduce the demand for municipal water supplies, reduce stormwater runoff, and provide a reliable water source for non-potable uses. However, potential ecological risks must be managed through proper design, operation, and maintenance of these systems. Using a rainwater collection system for houses has a significant role in sustainable water management and can contribute to a more sustainable future.


Questions? Look here.

Can't find an answer? Contact us at Contact Page or email [email protected]

Reviews

Login to write a comment

Waterlyst@ 2025 Waterlyst Inc. All rights reserved.

WaterLyst: Sustainable Water Solutions for a Healthy Planet

WaterLyst is your partner in optimizing water use and sustainability. We offer innovative water management solutions tailored to your specific needs. From industrial and commercial facilities to residential properties, we provide expert consulting, technology, and services to achieve water efficiency and resilience. Discover how we can help you conserve water, reduce costs, and minimize your environmental impact.